Current:Home > MyCalifornia court ruling could threaten key source of funding for disputed giant water tunnel project -ValueMetric
California court ruling could threaten key source of funding for disputed giant water tunnel project
View
Date:2025-04-25 09:39:50
SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — A California judge says a nearly 65-year-old law does not give the state permission to borrow the billions of dollars it would need to build a large water project, a decision that could threaten a key source of funding for a controversial plan backed by Gov. Gavin Newsom to build a massive underground tunnel that would reroute a big part of the state’s supply.
The Department of Water Resources approved a resolution in 2020 to borrow money for an unspecified “Delta Program.” The agency said it could borrow this money without asking for permission from the state Legislature because a law, last amended in 1959, says it can make changes to a portion of the State Water Project — a complex system of dams and canals that supplies water to about 27 million people.
But environmental groups and several Central Valley counties say that resolution was too broad. They say what the agency wants to build is a tunnel that would be outside the scope of the law. DWR’s latest proposal is to construct a tunnel about 45 miles (72 kilometers) long and 36 feet (10.9 meters) wide, able to carry 161 million gallons of water per minute out of the Central Valley and to the densely populated southern portion of the state.
On Tuesday, after years of lengthy court proceedings, Sacramento Superior Court Judge Kenneth C. Mennemeier agreed with the counties. He said the state’s definition of the project “leaves the door open” for the state to build whatever it wants, which he said is not allowed under the law.
“Although the Legislature plainly delegated broad authority to DWR, it did not delegate infinite authority,” Mennemeier wrote.
Mennemeier emphasized that his ruling was “quite narrow,” only applying to the Newsom administration’s unspecified “Delta Program” as defined in the DWR resolution.
Thomas Keeling, an attorney who represents six counties and various public water agencies, said it’s clear to him that the purpose of the bond resolutions approved by the Newsom administration in 2020 was to provide financing for the Delta tunnel project. He agreed the ruling is narrow because it doesn’t prevent the administration from finding other ways to pay for the project.
“That said, it would be a mistake to downplay the significance of this decision or to understate the obstacles that lie ahead for DWR in any subsequent effort to finance this taxpayer boondoggle,” he said.
Environmental groups and counties that oppose the project cheered the ruling as a blow to the tunnel’s financing. The project’s price tag was once put at $16 billion, but that was an old estimate for a previous plan. The state has not released updated estimates.
The DWR downplayed the significance of the ruling, although it said it disagreed with the decision and is considering an appeal. Margaret Mohr, deputy director of communications for the department, said the judge essentially rejected the broadness of the definition of the “Delta Program” and did not make a ruling specific to the tunnel.
“The judge has not said that DWR doesn’t have the authority to build the project or borrow money to pay for it,” Mohr said. Mohr added that “the Delta Conveyance Project is a critical part of California’s strategy to ensure a reliable water supply for millions of Californians — modernizing our water infrastructure to protect against the impacts of earthquakes, climate change, and more.”
The tunnel has been proposed — and disputed — for many years, earning widespread opposition from Central Valley communities that say it would harm their economies and the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta’s fragile ecosystem. The Newsom administration says the tunnel is a necessary upgrade of aging infrastructure that would help the state capture more water during intense rainstorms.
It’s not clear what other options the Department of Water Resources could pursue to pay for the project. Asking for approval from voters or the state Legislature would be difficult. Just last year, lawmakers insisted on exempting the tunnel project from a law Newsom signed aimed at speeding up how long it takes to build large infrastructure projects.
Newsom, however, has been steadfast in his support for the project. Last month, his administration completed a key environmental review — the final step of a lengthy state regulatory process. But the project still must complete a federal environmental review and obtain various state and federal permits — a process that is expected to last until 2026.
veryGood! (87712)
Related
- Federal court filings allege official committed perjury in lawsuit tied to Louisiana grain terminal
- Don Read, who led Montana to first national college football title, dies at 90
- Live updates | 6 killed overnight in an apparent Israeli airstrike on a home in southern Gaza
- Georgia deputy fatally struck by Alabama police car in high-speed chase across state lines
- Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
- Fire at home of Dolphins receiver Tyreek Hill started by child playing with cigarette lighter
- A judge in Oregon refuses to dismiss a 2015 climate lawsuit filed by youth
- 3-year-old Tennessee boy dies after being struck with a stray bullet on New Year's Eve
- Southern California rocked by series of earthquakes: Is a bigger one brewing?
- Trump lawyers urge court to hold special counsel Jack Smith in contempt in 2020 election case
Ranking
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- 'Bright as it was in 2020' Glowing bioluminescence waves return to Southern California beaches
- Striking doctors in England at loggerheads with hospitals over calls to return to work
- Who is Natalia Grace? What to know about subject of docuseries, ‘Natalia Speaks’
- Why we love Bear Pond Books, a ski town bookstore with a French bulldog 'Staff Pup'
- Why Pregnant Kailyn Lowry Is Considering Ozempic After She Gives Birth to Twins
- Feeling caucus confusion? Your guide to how Iowa works
- Keke Palmer Says She’s “Never Been So Happy” in Her Life Despite Darius Jackson Drama
Recommendation
Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
Katt Williams accuses Cedric the Entertainer of stealing his 'best joke' from the '90s
Police say there has been a shooting at a high school in Perry, Iowa; extent of injuries unclear
Claiborne ‘Buddy’ McDonald, a respected Mississippi judge and prosecutor, dies at 75
British golfer Charley Hull blames injury, not lack of cigarettes, for poor Olympic start
Armed ethnic alliance in northern Myanmar is said to have seized a city that was a key goal
AP Week in Pictures: Europe and Africa
Claiborne ‘Buddy’ McDonald, a respected Mississippi judge and prosecutor, dies at 75